Yongsheng 052 Fountain Pen Review

I bought a Lanxivi® Yongsheng 052 Century Pioneer Extra Fine Nib Fountain Pen, and had it delivered for the princely sum of nine dollars.

It’s an attractive pen. The gold accent lines on the cap and barrel line up horizontally, so you will have to twist the cap after replacing it to keep your OCD from driving you crazy.  If you have problems with anything like that. Like I do.

It has a solid clip that fits tightly to the cap. The cap clicks into place, and it the strongest cap to barrel mating that I have ever seen.  I’ve had caps come off in my pocket before, but I guarantee that this one will never have that problem. I’m sure it will loosen up some over time, but right now it takes so much effort to remove the cap that there is occasionally ink splatter from the nib due to the sudden release of the cap.

It’s a metal pen with a solid feel. It is a little on the thin side as fountain pens go, but not extremely so. It’s feels good in my hand, and is comfortable to use, posted or not.

At first, I inked it with Franklin-Christoph Black Magic ink.  They don’t say why they call it black magic.  Maybe it does cool shading things on parchment paper or something.  For those of us who use it on cheap paper, it is a good, solid black black.  I bought Aurora black when I started playing with fountain pens because it was said to be a very black black, but this stuff is darker. I highly recommend the F-C inks. Their prices are reasonable, and the quality is excellent.

It is advertised as an extra fine nib, but it appears to use the same nib as the Jinhao 9009 that I reviewed yesterday.  However, with this ink, it laid down a much wider line and uses a lot more ink than I would expect from a medium nib, much less a fine or extra fine. Also, in spite of the amount of ink usage, it skipped often. Pretty much every time I tried to write with it. Get it going, and it’s fine. Mostly. But the first letter is going to contain a skip. And it’ll bleed so much ink through cheap paper that it will occasionally mark the sheet below the one in use.

That made me sad. I wanted to love this pen. It looks good, and it feels good in my hand. But the performance of the Jinhao, which was several dollars cheaper, was orders of magnitude better.

Before giving up on the pen, I decided to clean it out and switch inks.  At my suggestion, B bought me a bottle of Manuscript ink from Hobby Lobby for my birthday back in December.  I refilled the pen with this stuff, figuring that since it is the cheapest ink that I have, it might be a good fit for the poorest performing pen that I’ve tried up to now.  I didn’t let it dry long enough, and at first it wrote gray.  Eventually, the water worked its way out, and I was able to get a fair evaluation of performance with the new ink.

I had to keep checking to make sure it was the same pen.  It performed flawlessly. No skips.  Fine line. Not extra fine, but a true fine. Normal ink usage. I haven’t tried the Black Magic ink in any of my other pens yet, but I have tried two other F-C colors in other pens with no problems, so I’m pretty sure there’s nothing wrong with the ink.  Maybe the pen just needed a good cleaning.  Maybe something about it doesn’t like the flow characteristics of the Black Magic formula.  I don’t know.  And I really don’t care.  I will try other inks in the pen as it goes dry, and if any earth-shattering revelations present themselves, I will update this review, or post a new one.

Bottom line: I was going to relegate this pen to the back corner of a drawer somewhere after my initial experience with it.  However, its second chance ensures that it will be a workhorse for me. Nine dollars. Beautiful, comfortable design. Excellent performance, at least with six dollar per bottle Hobby Lobby ink. Grumpy like.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Yongsheng 052 Fountain Pen Review

  1. Just be sure you don’t use India ink in a fountain pen–the pigment-based inks dry solid and create clogs that it takes a paperclip to get out of the feed. They’re great for dip pens, where you need them to cling to the pen to have enough ink to write with, but not for fountain pens. Fountain pen inks are dye based.

    • alaskan454 says:

      Thanks for the heads up. Everything I’ve tried so far is supposed to be for fountain pens, but as my addiction progresses, I’ll likely try out more new inks, too. Now that I know, I’ll make sure to get the right stuff.

  2. Kitsy says:

    I just bought this pen and it’s arriving tomorrow as of writing this. I noticed you mentioned that it skipped at first, but I have to say, you should always be sure to wash these cheaper pens before inking them up, because tiny metal shavings from the manufacturing process tend to be stuck in the feed and/or nib, and a good cleaning will generally get it out. Blame the cheap quality control, but they’re less that $15, so you can’t expect much. From the sound of it, after cleaning it and inking it with the second ink, the clog was released, so It looks like I have a decent pen on the way. Do you have anything to say about it after a few months of use though?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s